Margaret McCartney: Stop relying on charity.
نویسنده
چکیده
In the past week three young people have come to my door, with lanyards and branded T shirts, asking me to pledge regular donations to charity. Each represented a big, national, medical charity, the kinds withmarketingmanagers and campaign teams. I said no to each one, which prompted two of them to enter into sales pitches about how helping to set up a direct debit would “just take a minute.” Both looked annoyed when, again, I said no thanks. Doorstep selling is a good way to pressurise people—and a bad way for people to understand the potential recipients of their money. I want to give to charities in the most evidence based way possible: I want to support organisations without unjustifiably high administration costs, ones that act rationally and plan for the long term. More fundamental problems, though, affect the current model of charity in the United Kingdom. Currently, charitable organisations compete with one another to attract donations. Animal charities receive more money than charities that support homeless people, disabled people, or older people. Giving money on the basis of a cause’s popularity may mean that some groups with greater needs miss out. The Roy Castle Lung Cancer Foundation’s income was £4.8m in 2013; Breakthrough Breast Cancer raised £16.3m.Yet 22% of the UK’s deaths from cancer result from lung cancer, compared with 7% from breast cancer. Are we perhaps more reluctant to give to a charity for a disease many people associate with smoking? Funding through charity cannot be guaranteed, because it depends on individual judgment. It seems wrong that vital needs—research, personal care, or support—are paid for in this way. Another example is hospices, which are usually funded only in part by the NHS, meaning that their availability depends on the generosity of the community. Surely, if we have evidence of a need for hospices or specialist nurses, their cost should be met by public funds. Charitable donation is being used to fill gaps that should be filled through taxation. Surveys presented at the British Sociological Association in 2013 found that the poorest 20% of people gave 3.2% of their gross income to charity, compared with only 0.9% of gross income from the richest 20%. 6 In other words, proportionally, this system has the poorest people subsidising the richest. Follow Margaret on Twitter, @mgtmccartney
منابع مشابه
Margaret McCartney: The unacceptable cost of non-NHS screening.
The NHS is making impossible choices about what to fund. And yet, routinely, doctors are expected to pick up the pieces from non-NHS services. I’ve written before about my distaste for private health screening companies, which, after frightening citizens into their offices and relieving them of hundreds of pounds, hand back false positives and reams of thoughtless testing to the NHS. GPs have t...
متن کاملMargaret McCartney: We don't need nannying for colds.
Winter means handkerchiefs, and the NHS’s response this season is a campaign to the tune of the NHS Choir. Sparkling and tuneful, they extol messages to keep warm, stock up on food and hot drinks, and keep an eye out for older members of the community. But they also tell us, “See your local pharmacist at the first sign of a cold.” The NHS website repeats this: “Always seek advice from your phar...
متن کاملMargaret McCartney: Nurses must be allowed to exercise professional judgment.
It has come to our attention that this Views and Reviews paper (BMJ 2017;356:j1548, doi:10.1136/bmj.j1548) contains an error. The article refers to "guidance written by the BMA, the Resuscitation Council, and the Royal College of Midwives." The guidance referred to is a joint publication from the BMA, the Resuscitation Council, and the Royal College of Nursing, not the Royal College of Midwives...
متن کاملMargaret McCartney: Innovation without sufficient evidence is a disservice to all.
Breeding with the vigour of rabbits, a variety of private GP services are springing up and jostling for your attention. Why spend hours phoning your own GP when you can choose a private GP by looks and price, having immediate access online or by app without needing to leave your home? Recruitment for GPs in such companies is increasingly competitive, with advertisements promising hourly rates a...
متن کاملMargaret McCartney: Why GPs are stressed.
7. Your patients have an average of three issues to discuss, and you’re keen to talk about the ongoing need for drugs, aims of care, and informed choices. You also have—in 10 minutes or so—to consider targets for smoking cessation, advance care planning, flu vaccinations, and polypharmacy reviews. You’re meant to discuss bowel screening, give opportunistic advice on exercise, and raise the prob...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید
ثبت ناماگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید
ورودعنوان ژورنال:
- BMJ
دوره 350 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2015